Courtney Baker-Richardson made his first start for Tamworth FC on Tuesday night.
The striker on loan from Coventry City to gain some match experience, was named in the starting eleven for their Birmingham Senior Cup tie at Banbury United, who had knocked out Coventry Sphinx in the First Round.
Baker-Richardson did well on his start and played until stoppage time in the second half when he was replaced by Fenton, in a game which Tamworth won 1-0 thanks to a 23rd minute Andy Haworth goal.
Tamworth will meet holders Hednesford Town, who beat Birmingham City, in the Semi-Final